Diminished Value Rights — State by State.
Diminished value law varies significantly across the United States. Some states allow recovery from your own insurer; most allow only third-party claims. Statutes of limitations range from 2 to 6 years. The strongest states have explicit case law; weaker states leave claimants with no statutory hook at all. This guide covers what diminished value rights actually look like in each state.
Where Your Accident Happened Determines Your Recovery Path.
Diminished value is a state-law claim. The rules that govern recovery — whether first-party recovery is allowed, what statute of limitations applies, what bad-faith remedies exist, what small claims court limits are — are entirely a function of the state where the accident occurred. A claim that's a slam-dunk in Georgia may not be recoverable in Michigan. The same vehicle, same damage, same insurer, different result.
All 50 states + DC are now live — a complete 51-jurisdiction database covering every U.S. diminished value framework. From Georgia's plaintiff-friendly first- and third-party recovery to North Dakota's statutory limit on DV recovery, from California's pure comparative negligence to DC's pure contributory negligence, every jurisdiction has its own controlling case law, statute of limitations, comparative-fault rule, and small claims procedure documented in this database. Each guide contains full case law analysis, filing procedures, and demand letter strategy specific to that state's appellate authority.
- First and Third-Party — both first-party (your own insurer) and third-party recovery allowed. Georgia is the only state in this category.
- Third-Party Only — recovery allowed only from at-fault driver's insurer. Most states.
- Limited Third-Party — recovery technically allowed but with significant practical barriers. A handful of states.
- Effectively Barred — case law or policy language makes recovery extremely difficult. Few states.
State Comparison — Live Guides.
Quick reference for all 51 live state guides — every U.S. jurisdiction. Each row links to the full guide with case-by-case analysis, filing procedures, and state-specific demand letter strategy.
← Swipe to see full table →
| State | Recovery Type | Statute of Limitations | Small Claims Limit | Leading Authority |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama | Third-Party Only | 2 years (§ 6-2-38) | $6,000 + Pure Contributory | Joiner v. Holland & Woodard; Pritchett blocks first-party |
| Alaska | Third-Party (Evolving) | 2 years (AS 09.10.070) | $10,000 (Pure Comparative) | Willett v. State of Alaska (1992); Restatement § 928 acknowledged |
| Arizona | Third-Party Only | 2 years (A.R.S. § 12-542) | $3,500 | Oliver v. Henry, 227 Ariz. 514 (Ct. App. 2011) |
| Arkansas | Third-Party + UMPD (Hit-and-Run) | 3 years (§ 16-56-105) | $5,000 | MFA Insurance Co. v. Citizens Nat. Bank (Ark. 1977) |
| California | Third-Party Only | 3 years (CCP § 338(c)) | $12,500 | CACI 3903J (2016); Baldwin v. AAA |
| Colorado | Third-Party Only | 3 years (C.R.S. § 13-80-101) | $7,500 | Larson v. Long, 74 Colo. 152 (1923); Trujillo v. Wilson (1948) |
| Connecticut | Third-Party Only | 2 years (§ 52-584) | $5,000 (no appeal) | Littlejohn v. Elionsky (1944); Harding v. Spulick (2024) |
| Delaware | Third-Party Only | 2 years (10 Del. C. § 8107) | $25,000 | Delledonne (Del. Sup.) blocks first-party; tort recovery available |
| District of Columbia | Third-Party Only | 3 years (DC Code § 12-301) | $10,000 + Pure Contributory | Standard property damage tort framework; pure contributory bar |
| Florida | Third-Party Only | 4 years (§ 95.11(3)) | $8,000 | McHale; Fla. Stat. § 626.9743 |
| Georgia | First & Third-Party | 4 years (O.C.G.A. § 9-3-32) | $15,000 | State Farm v. Mabry, 274 Ga. 498 (2001) |
| Hawaii | Third-Party (Evolving) | 2 years (HRS § 657-7) | $5,000 | County of Kauai v. Pacific Standard Life (Haw. 1982) — real property DV recognized |
| Idaho | Third-Party (Evolving) | 3 years (Idaho Code § 5-218) | $5,000 (no attorneys) | Boel v. Stewart Title (Idaho 2002) — real property DV recognized |
| Illinois | Third-Party + UMPD | 5 years (735 ILCS 5/13-205) | $10,000 | Trailmobile v. Higgs, 12 Ill. App. 3d 323 (1973) |
| Indiana | Third-Party + UMPD | 2 years (§ 34-11-2-4) | $10,000 | Wiese-GMC v. Wells (1993); Allgood v. Meridian (2005) |
| Iowa | Third-Party Only | 5 years (Iowa Code § 614.1) | $6,500 | Long v. McAllister (1982); Hawkeye Motors (1995); Papenheim (1995) |
| Kansas | Third-Party Only | 2 years (K.S.A. § 60-513) | $4,000 | Broadie v. Randall, 113 Kan. 357 (1923) |
| Kentucky | Third-Party Only | 2 years (KRS 304.39-230) | $2,500 | Muncie v. Wiesemann (Ky. 2018) — stigma damages doctrine |
| Louisiana | Third-Party + UMPD | 2 years* (Act 423, 2024) | $5,000 | Orillac v. Solomon (2000); LA R.S. 9:2800.17 (explicit DV statute) |
| Maine | Third-Party Only | 6 years (14 M.R.S.A. § 752) | $6,000 | Collins v. Kelley (Me. 1935) — 90 years of authority |
| Maryland | 3rd-Party + Mandatory UMPD | 3 years (§ 5-101) | $5,000 | Fred Frederick Motors (1971); MIA Bulletin 24-8 (2024) |
| Massachusetts | Third-Party (Policy Specific) | 3 years (Ch. 260, § 2A) | $7,000 | McGilloway (2021); Cubberley (2025) |
| Michigan | Mini-Tort ($3K cap) | 3 years (MCL 600.5805) | Sm. Claims Div. | MCL 500.3135(3)(e); No-fault statute |
| Minnesota | Third-Party Only | 6 years (Minn. Stat. § 541.05) | $15,000 | O'Connor v. Schwartz (1975); Restatement § 928; Rinkel (1959) |
| Mississippi | Third-Party + UMPD | 3 years (§ 15-1-49) | $3,500 (Pure Comparative) | Both-elements common law; Miss. Code § 11-7-15 |
| Missouri | Third-Party Only | 5 years (§ 516.120) | $5,000 | Rook v. John F. Oliver Trucking (1977) |
| Montana | Third-Party (Evolving) | 2 years (§ 27-2-207) | $7,000 | Hop v. Safeco (Mont. 2011) — DV is "open question" |
| Nebraska | Third-Party (Uncertain) | 4 years (§ 25-207) | $3,900 (no attorneys) | No reported authority either way; Restatement § 928 framework |
| Nevada | Third-Party Only | 3 years (NRS § 11.190(3)(c)) | $10,000 | Dugan v. Gotsopoulos (Nev. 2001); NV Jury Instruction 10.09 |
| New Hampshire | Third-Party (Evolving) | 3 years (RSA 508:4) | $10,000 + No Mandatory Insurance | No reported authority; only U.S. state without mandatory auto insurance |
| New Jersey | Third-Party + UMPD | 6 years (N.J.S.A. § 2A:14-1) | $20,000 (SCP) | Jones v. Lahn (1949); Fanfarillo (1980); Panter (2019) |
| New Mexico | Third-Party + UMPD (Hit-and-Run) | 4 years (§ 37-1-4) | $10,000 (Pure Comparative) | Hubbard v. Albuquerque Truck Center (N.M. 1998) — stigma damages |
| New York | Third-Party Only | 3 years (CPLR § 214(4)) | $10,000 NYC / $5,000 elsewhere | Franklin Corp v. Prahler, 932 N.Y.S.2d 610 (4th Dep't 2011) |
| North Carolina | Third-Party Only | 3 years (N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-52) | $10,000 | N.C. Gen. Stat. § 20-279.21 (third-party appraisal clause) |
| North Dakota | ⚠️ NOT Recoverable | 6 years (§ 28-01-16) | $15,000 (FINAL — no appeal) | § 32-03-09.1 + Sullivan v. Pulkrabek limit recovery to lesser of repair cost or DV |
| Ohio | Third-Party + UMPD | 2 years (ORC § 2305.10) | $6,000 | Falter v. Toledo (1959); Rakich v. Anthem (2007); Hyden (2024) |
| Oklahoma | Third-Party Only | 2 years (12 O.S. § 95) | $10,000 | Brennen v. Aston (2003); OUJI 4.14; 23 O.S. § 61 |
| Oregon | 1st + 3rd-Party + UMPD | 6 years (ORS 12.080) | $10,000 + ORS 20.080 | Rossier (1930); Gonzales v. Farmers; ORS 20.080 fee-shifting |
| Pennsylvania | Third-Party Only | 2 years (42 Pa.C.S.A. § 5524) | $12,000 | Holt v. Pariser (1947); Restatement § 928; 42 P.S. § 8371 |
| Rhode Island | Third-Party + UMPD (Hit-and-Run) | 10 YEARS (§ 9-1-13) | $2,500 (no plaintiff appeal) | LONGEST SOL in country; mandatory $25K UMPD covers DV |
| South Carolina | 3rd-Party + Mandatory UMPD | 3 years (§ 15-3-530) | $7,500 + Arbitration | Newman v. Brown (1955); SC Property Damage Arbitration ($10 fee) |
| South Dakota | Third-Party (Evolving) | 6 years (§ 15-2-13) | $12,000 (Slight/Gross) | Culhane (S.D. 2005) blocks first-party; tort framework supports third-party |
| Tennessee | Limited Third-Party | 3 years (T.C.A. § 28-3-105) | $25,000 | GEICO v. Bloodworth (2007); Grimes v. Hancock (2012) |
| Texas | Third-Party Only | 2 years (Tex. CPRC § 16.003) | $20,000 | Parkway Co. v. Woodruff, 901 S.W.2d 434 (Tex. 1995) |
| Utah | Third-Party + UMPD | 3 years (§ 78B-2-307) | $11,000 | Metcalf v. Mellen (Utah 1920) — 105 years; Utah Code § 78B-5-818 |
| Vermont | Third-Party + UMPD | 3 years (12 V.S.A. § 512) | $5,000 (50% bar) | Standard tort framework; VT UMPD covers DV (unusual for evolving state) |
| Virginia | Third-Party Only | 5 years (Va. Code § 8.01-243) | $5,000 | Averett v. Shircliff, 218 Va. 202 (1977); Va. Code § 46.2-1600 |
| Washington | First & Third-Party | 3 years (RCW 4.16.080) | $10,000 | Moeller v. Farmers, 173 Wn.2d 264 (2011); Grothe v. Kushnivich (2022) |
| West Virginia | Third-Party + Mandatory UMPD | 2 years (§ 55-2-12) | $10,000 + Structural Damage Required | Ellis v. King (W. Va. 1990) — narrow construction; mandatory $25K UMPD covers DV |
| Wisconsin | Third-Party Only | 6 years (Wis. Stat. § 893.52) | $10,000 | Hellenbrand v. Hilliard (2004); Hawes (1981); Wildin (2001) |
| Wyoming | Third-Party (Evolving) | 4 years (§ 1-3-105) | $7,000 (51% bar) | Miller v. Campbell County (Wyo. 1995) — DV recognized in inverse condemnation |
Small claims limits and statutes of limitations are state-specific. SOL begins running on the date of the accident in most jurisdictions. Verify your state's procedural rules before filing.
State law tells you what's recoverable. Your insurer's playbook tells you how to recover it.
Knowing California allows third-party DV recovery is half the battle. Knowing how Allstate handles California claims, what State Farm's response cycle looks like, or why GEICO retains the appraisal clause where State Farm has removed it — that's the other half. Eight insurer-specific playbooks now live:
Need an appraisal that holds up in any state?
Our USPAP-compliant diminished value reports are built to defend against insurer formula-based offers in every U.S. jurisdiction.
Get Your DV Report — from $49.99DV claims by insurer:
